tech
New York Times Asks Whether Smart TVs Still Need Streaming Boxes

The New York Times this week put a plain question to anyone who has bought a television in the past few years: now that most sets ship with their own built-in streaming software, is a separate box such as an Apple TV, a Google TV player or a Roku streaming device still worth buying? The Times report raises the question rather than settling it, reflecting a shift in the television market that has made a once-obvious purchase — the add-on streaming puck — optional for some buyers and still necessary for others.
What Prompted the Question?
For more than a decade, buying a television and buying the device that streams Netflix, YouTube or Disney+ on it were separate decisions. Televisions came with a remote and a tuner; the smart features arrived later, bolted on through a Roku, an Apple TV or a Chromecast plugged into an HDMI port. The Times' framing acknowledges that this division has blurred as manufacturers have folded full streaming operating systems directly into their sets, selling the software and the hardware as one product rather than two.
That shift is why the question is being asked now rather than five years ago: a buyer walking into a store today is less likely to be choosing a television and then separately shopping for a streaming box, and more likely to be choosing between televisions that already run different platforms under the hood.
Does Connectivity Standardization Change the Calculation?
One factor bearing on the decision is how easily devices from different manufacturers work together once they are in the same living room. HTT News reported in September on an update to the Matter smart home standard designed to simplify how connected devices from different brands communicate with one another. A standard built for broader smart-home compatibility is relevant to the television question because it speaks to the same underlying friction: whether gear from competing companies needs to be reconciled by the shopper, or whether that reconciliation increasingly happens behind the scenes.
Whether a television's built-in software is capable enough on its own is becoming the operative question for shoppers deciding if they still need another box under the set.
For households that already use Matter-compatible smart home devices — locks, lights, sensors — alongside their television, the degree to which a TV's native platform plays well with that ecosystem, versus requiring a dedicated streaming device to bridge the gap, is part of the same practical calculation the Times piece surfaces.
Who Still Has a Reason to Buy a Separate Box?
The Times does not claim the answer is the same for every household, and the reporting leaves room for both outcomes to be reasonable depending on the set in question, its age, and how it is used. A newer television with a current, well-supported operating system is a different proposition than an older set whose built-in software has not been updated in years — a distinction the report treats as central to the decision rather than incidental to it.
Households managing several streaming accounts, multiple televisions on different platforms, or a mix of smart-home accessories tied to a specific ecosystem are the ones most likely to still find a standalone device useful, since it can offer a consistent interface across sets that otherwise run different built-in software.
How Should a Household Decide?
The practical test the Times frames is less about brand loyalty and more about whether the television in front of a given household already does what a box would add. That is a household-by-household judgment rather than a blanket rule, and it is one that changes as built-in TV software continues to be updated — or, in older sets, stops being updated at all.
What to Watch
- Whether television manufacturers extend software update support for built-in platforms to match the multi-year support windows dedicated streaming devices typically offer.
- Whether further Matter standard updates ease the handoff between a TV's native software and separate smart-home or streaming hardware already in a household.
- Whether buyers increasingly treat the choice of smart TV platform — rather than a later streaming-box purchase — as the primary decision point when shopping for a new television.
The Times' reporting frames this as an active, unresolved question for consumers rather than a settled verdict, and the answer for any single household depends on the age of its television, the platform it runs, and how tightly it is already woven into other connected devices at home.
Questions
Does a smart TV still need a separate streaming device like Apple TV or Roku?
A New York Times report examines that question directly, weighing whether built-in smart TV software has advanced enough to make an additional streaming box unnecessary for many viewers, while noting the answer varies by television age and platform.
How does the Matter smart home standard relate to smart TVs and streaming boxes?
An update to Matter, reported by HTT News in September, is designed to make it easier for connected devices from different manufacturers — including televisions and the hardware that plugs into them — to work together, which bears on whether a separate streaming device is still needed.